Estimates

An estimate is an educated guess of the time, effort, or resources required to complete a task or project. Estimates are essential for planning, budgeting, and scheduling purposes.

Creating accurate estimates is a crucial skill in the workplace, particularly when planning projects, tasks, or resource allocation. Good estimates help set realistic expectations, keep projects on track, and avoid overcommitting. This guide covers the essential steps and best practices for creating effective estimates.

Accurate estimates are valuable in several areas:

• Resource Allocation: Helps in assigning the right amount of resources (time, money, people) to a task or project.
• Stakeholder Communication: Sets clear expectations with clients, managers, or team members.
• Project Planning: Ensures that projects are planned with realistic timelines and budgets.
• Risk Management: Identifies potential risks and allows for contingency planning.

Historical Data

Use historical data from similar past tasks to inform your estimates. Reviewing descriptions, comments, estimates, time logs, and outcomes from previous tasks helps you understand the scope, time and effort needed, and potential risks for the new task.

• Reference Past Projects: Look at previous projects or tasks that are similar in nature.
• Adjust for Differences: Consider any differences in scope, complexity, or resources when using historical data to inform your estimate.

Creating an Estimate

Step 1: Define the Scope

Clearly defining the scope of the task is the first step in creating an accurate estimate.

• Understand the Requirements: Gather all relevant details about the task, including expected deliverables, inputs, dependencies, constraints, and potential risks.
• Break Down the Work: Divide the task into smaller sub-tasks. This approach provides a comprehensive view of the scope and helps avoid oversights. Smaller tasks are also easier to estimate accurately.

Step 2: Estimate Time and Effort

Estimate the time and effort required to complete the task, considering both the actual work and any additional overhead, such as communication, meetings, testing, reviews, documentation, and preparing deliverables. If these have not been broken down into separate sub-tasks, include them in your overall estimate.

You may use a combination of approaches to estimate the time and effort needed:

• Expert Judgment: Base your estimate on your own experience or by consulting with team members who have experience with similar tasks.
• Analogous Estimating: Use estimates from similar previous tasks as a basis, adjusting for any differences in scope or complexity.
• Parametric Estimating: Use measurable aspects of the task (e.g., number of pages, fields, variations, sizes) to estimate the time and effort required.

Step 3: Consider Task Complexity and Risks

While adding a buffer to every estimate is conventional wisdom, this approach can lead to inaccuracies, either overestimating or underestimating the impact of unknowns on the time and effort required to complete a task. A more effective approach is to carefully consider the task's complexity and associated risks.

• Complexity: The time and effort required to complete tasks can vary depending on the skill level of the team member assigned. Low-complexity tasks may be executed with little variation in time by both low- and high-skilled team members, whereas high-complexity tasks can require substantially more time for less experienced team members.
• Risks: External factors beyond your control can impact the time needed or the schedule. This includes dependencies like inputs from third parties, the completion of other tasks, or vague or incomplete requirements at the time of estimation. These risks can lead to additional work, rework, or delays.

To properly account for complexity and risks, consider providing three scenarios instead of a single estimate:

• Optimistic (Low) Estimate: Best-case scenario with minimal impact from complexity and risks.
• Pessimistic (High) Estimate: Worst-case scenario with significant impact from complexity and risks.
• Most Likely Estimate: A reasonable expectation considering the likely impact of complexity and risks.

Providing estimates in this form is acceptable. Managers can then decide on the final estimate to use for proposals and project plans. A common approach to determine the final estimate is to use the following formula:

$$Estimate=\frac{Optimistic+4\times MostLikely+Pessimistic}{6}$$

Unable to Estimate for the Worst-Case Scenario?

There may be situations where providing an upper-limit or worst-case estimate for a task is not feasible. This could be due to a lack of knowledge or experience necessary to complete the task, or due to significant risk factors—such as vague requirements or dependencies on third parties. In these cases, it's essential to handle the situation carefully and communicate the uncertainty to your manager.

Identifying the Cause

If you are unable to estimate a worst-case scenario, start by identifying the root cause:

• Lack of Knowledge or Experience: When you lack the necessary knowledge or experience to accurately estimate the task (and nobody else in the team can help), it's important to recognize this limitation early on.

• Excessive Risk Factors: In cases where there are significant risk factors (e.g., unclear requirements or third-party dependencies), providing a reliable estimate may be difficult. Ensure that these uncertainties are clearly communicated to your manager and discuss how they may impact the estimation process.

Approaches to Handle Uncertainty

There are several ways to handle tasks where a worst-case scenario cannot be estimated:

1. Additional Research: If the issue is a lack of knowledge or experience, it may be necessary to invest time in research, learning, or prototyping. Discuss with your manager how much time you believe is needed to gather the required information. The manager may approve this additional effort if it is reasonable and fits within the timeline for delivering proposals or quotes.

2. Wait for Discovery: If the unknowns are too significant to provide an estimate upfront, indicate that no final estimate is available at this stage. The estimate can be revisited and finalized once the necessary information is obtained during the Discovery phase of the project.

3. Billing on an Hourly Basis: In situations where there is substantial uncertainty, your manager may decide to propose billing on an hourly basis rather than offering a fixed estimate. This allows for flexibility in scope and ensures that time spent on the task is fairly compensated.

4. Assumption-Based Estimates: Another approach is to create an estimate based on specific assumptions. If this route is chosen, it is critical to document the assumptions and requirements in detail. The manager will highlight these assumptions in the client proposal, and if they later prove to be incorrect, the estimate can be updated to reflect the new scope or understanding of the task.

Importance of Communication

In all cases, it is essential to communicate any uncertainty or inability to provide a worst-case estimate to your manager. Work together to decide on the best course of action, ensuring that any risks or unknowns are documented and accounted for. This transparency allows for more informed decision-making and helps mitigate potential risks as the project progresses.

Best Practices

• Be Realistic: Avoid both under- and overestimating. Realistic estimates are crucial for successful project outcomes.
• Provide Context: Clearly document assumptions, considerations, and approaches used during the estimation process. This provides context for stakeholders and makes it easier to revisit the estimate later if needed.

---

Consistently applying these principles will improve the accuracy of your estimates over time, build trust with stakeholders, and contribute to the overall success of our projects at Lyquix.